Why Appeasement Fails to Deter Abusers in Society and Politics
Written on
Understanding the Ineffectiveness of Appeasement
Recently, I’ve come across numerous discussions about attempting to engage in rational dialogue with individuals holding extremist views, such as Q-Anon supporters, racists, and certain political factions. Additionally, I've heard calls for empathy towards those who express misogynistic sentiments.
It's worth noting that the advice to engage with these individuals often stems from a misguided belief that rational conversation can change their minds. However, some advocates of this approach may have ulterior motives when suggesting negotiation.
I firmly stand against those who promote harmful policies and believe in self-defense against intimidation. It's essential to block or delete any disrespectful or harmful comments. Why? Because appeasement never deters bullies.
Photo by Jakayla Toney on Unsplash
Reflecting on childhood experiences, we recall how bullies would resort to physical aggression or spread malicious rumors to exert control over others. They often continued this behavior until their victim retaliated, at which point they would complain and cease their attacks.
As adults, we discourage physical retaliation due to potential legal consequences, hoping instead that the bully will mature or "see the error of their ways." This dynamic can manifest in various forms of abuse, including domestic violence, toxic workplaces, and political coercion. For the purpose of this discussion, I want to focus on adult bullies—those who inflict harm simply because they can.
The Spectrum of Adult Bullies
Bullies come in many forms, including extremists, misogynists, workplace aggressors, and domestic abusers. Most adult bullies persist in their behavior until they face repercussions.
Photo by Markus Spiske on Unsplash
Bullies typically target individuals they perceive as unable to fight back. When they successfully provoke a reaction, they often escalate their behavior. To comprehend why ignoring or appeasing bullies is ineffective, we must delve into the psychology of bullying.
Bullies derive a sense of power from their actions, often motivated by insecurity or a need to dominate. They mistreat others to elevate their own status. The reality is that bullies are unable to handle the consequences of their actions but will continue their behavior until faced with resistance.
Photo by Ilayza on Unsplash
For bullies, ignoring their behavior signals that they have "won." They interpret your unwillingness to engage as a sign of submission, leading them to escalate their aggression. Conversely, when they face retaliation, they recognize a boundary—something they despise. If the consequences are significant enough, they may cease their abusive behavior entirely.
Effective Strategies for Dealing with Bullies
To effectively counteract bullying behavior, consider the following strategies:
- Block and Ignore: If someone is trying to provoke you through trolling or dishonest debate, the best response is to block them and refuse to engage. Abusers thrive on attention and conflict; denying them this can be powerful.
- Shunning: Ignoring a bully is not the same as shunning. The latter inflicts a psychological pain that can deter further aggression.
- Self-Defense: If physically assaulted, it is crucial to defend yourself. Sometimes, only a physical response will convey the seriousness of the situation.
- Addressing Emotional Manipulation: If someone threatens self-harm as a form of emotional blackmail, involve authorities if necessary. This action can serve as a deterrent.
- Legal Action: Legal repercussions can significantly deter bullies, particularly in a corporate context.
- Shaming: While not universally effective, exposing bullies can sometimes yield results, especially in political contexts.
- Engagement with Institutions: If bullies hold positions in institutions, disengaging or promoting non-bullies can be effective strategies.
Photo by Danny Howe on Unsplash
The Reality of Adult Bullies and Their Tactics
In summary, recognizing the futility of appeasement in addressing bullying behavior is crucial. Instead, a proactive approach that includes boundaries and consequences can significantly alter the dynamics of power.
This video titled "Treating Trauma: When Working with Please and Appease" delves into the complexities of managing trauma and the importance of setting boundaries in relationships.
The second video, "Rigid Narcissists And The Failed Strategy Of Appeasement," explores the challenges of dealing with narcissistic personalities and the ineffectiveness of appeasement as a strategy.