The Unexpected Hanging Paradox: A Deep Dive into Logic's Dilemmas
Written on
Chapter 1: Introduction to the Paradox
The Unexpected Hanging Paradox presents a fascinating challenge to logical philosophy. While some modern game theorists might claim it falls under their purview, this puzzle predates contemporary game theory by many years.
The first documented discussion of this paradox came from Donald John O'Connor, a philosopher at the University of Exeter, in 1948. His work sparked a lively debate among logicians, mathematicians, and philosophers, leading to numerous articles exploring the paradox's implications. In 1951, Michael Scriven, a professor specializing in the logic of science, remarked on this paradox's significance, stating, "A new and powerful paradox has come to light."
Despite extensive discourse over the years, a consensus on the paradox remains elusive. This essay will first outline a straightforward yet classic rendition of the paradox, followed by a proposed resolution. Finally, we'll delve into some intriguing historical context surrounding this enigma. Let's dive in!
The Unexpected Hanging Paradox — The Setup
Our narrative begins with a hapless prisoner who, in a moment of desperation, steals a coconut. Almost escaping her fate, she is caught by a group of children and reported to the shopkeeper, who then notifies the authorities.
In this fictional realm, the legal system is notably harsh. The prisoner is taken into custody immediately. On the following day, Saturday, she stands before the judge alongside her lawyer, who pronounces the following sentence:
"I sentence you to death by hanging! Your execution will occur at noon on one of the seven days next week, and you will not know in advance which day it will be."
Stunned by this judgment, the prisoner is led back to her cell, accompanied by her lawyer. The judge is known for his unwavering integrity, so she realizes that he will fulfill his sentence.
As they walk away, the lawyer, wearing a relieved expression, suddenly exclaims, "What luck!