A Shocking Tale of Betrayal and Murder in a Small Town
Written on
Chapter 1: The Disappearance of Noreen Boyle
The haunting story of Noreen Boyle captures the attention of the nation.
Noreen’s life was tragically cut short when her husband, Dr. John “Jack” Boyle, was awakened by alarming noises in their new home. Concerned friends of Noreen quickly alerted the police, leading to the discovery of her body buried beneath the concrete floor.
Noreen was a 44-year-old mother of two, residing in Mansfield, Ohio, with her 46-year-old husband, John, a well-respected physician and the owner of the largest medical practice in Richland County. Their family appeared to enjoy a comfortable lifestyle, with children attending private schools and Noreen indulging in shopping trips. However, behind closed doors, John exhibited troubling behavior.
Section 1.1: The Dark Side of a Respected Doctor
Collier, their son, often witnessed John’s explosive temper directed at both Noreen and himself. One incident stands out vividly; during a gaming session, John erupted in rage, hurling video games at Collier and berating him.
“What are you?” John shouted.
“I’m a stupid little fat boy,” Collier replied, echoing his father’s words in fear.
Despite their community’s admiration for John, whispers of his infidelities were well-known. Noreen endured the pain until she could no longer accept John’s betrayal, especially after he introduced one of his girlfriends to Collier, who noticed a ring resembling his mother's.
Subsection 1.1.1: A Turning Point
Noreen decided to file for divorce, but John persuaded her to stay, promising a fresh start in a new home in Erie, Pennsylvania. On the eve of the new year in 1989, Collier was jolted awake by a horrifying scream from his parents' bedroom, followed by two unsettling thuds.
When Collier sought answers from John the next day, he was met with a fabricated story about Noreen taking a vacation. Sensing something was amiss, Collier took matters into his own hands, contacting his mother’s friends to report her disappearance.
Section 1.2: The Investigation Begins
As the authorities investigated, John maintained his narrative, claiming Noreen had left him due to his infidelities. Collier, however, insisted that his mother wouldn’t abandon him. With his grandmother backing John's account, the police were led astray.
In the following days, Collier’s suspicions grew as he noted John's peculiar behavior upon returning from Erie. He observed bruises on his father’s arms, a detail that raised alarm. A detective took an interest in Collier's insights, leading him to share significant findings, including photographs of John with his girlfriend.
Chapter 2: The Unraveling Truth
As the investigation progressed, John’s actions became increasingly suspicious. He had pressured a real estate agent to hasten the move into the new house, raising questions about his intentions.
Watch: The Mad Dr. Von Cosel TAKES HER CORPSE HOME, and Lives with Her for 7 Years. At Key West Cemetery.
The authorities learned that John had rented a jackhammer days before Noreen's disappearance, prompting further investigation. When they searched the newly renovated basement, they uncovered a disturbing secret hidden beneath the fresh concrete.
A foul odor led investigators to a decomposed body, confirming their worst fears—Noreen’s remains were found.
Watch: This Man Dug a Hole in His Backyard He Was Not Ready For What He Discovered There.
Section 2.1: The Aftermath of the Discovery
John was arrested, and Collier faced the heartbreaking reality of losing both his mother and father. He bravely testified against John, who was ultimately convicted of murder and sentenced to 20 years to life in prison.
Years later, DNA testing confirmed that the remains found in the basement were indeed Noreen's. This case remains a tragic reminder of the hidden darkness that can exist beneath the surface of seemingly ordinary lives.
Welcome to Medium. I write about tragic stories, primarily in the true crime genre. For more, visit my official website. Thank you for reading.
Home — Lioness Rue
I focus on researching and narrating crime stories.
lionessrue.com
I also launched a new true crime YouTube channel. Explore our videos, and if you appreciate our content, consider subscribing, liking, and sharing.
The True Crime Pub
?? Welcome to The True Crime Pub. I share true crime narratives. ??
www.youtube.com