Understanding Net Profit Participation in Hollywood Screenwriting
Written on
Chapter 1: The Allure of Net Profit Participation
The term "net profit participation" may sound appealing, but the reality is often quite different.
Whenever you sell a screenplay, pitch a project, or secure a writing role at a Hollywood studio, you’re likely to encounter a substantial contract. Typically, these contracts will contain clauses stipulating that you, as the writer, will receive a percentage of the so-called "net profit proceeds." This percentage usually falls between 2.5% and 5%, with the latter being the norm. The terminology itself is inviting: 'profit' indicates money, and 'participation' suggests a collaborative effort, almost like a chorus singing "Kum Ba Yah" while sharing the financial rewards.
However, the crux of the issue lies in the term 'net.' In Hollywood, net profits often equate to nothing.
Creative accounting practices make it exceedingly rare for a film to actually report a net profit. If you doubt this, consider films like Rain Man, Forrest Gump, and My Big Fat Greek Wedding—each of these has been labeled as not generating a single dollar in net profit.
And if a film isn’t deemed to have net profit, you won’t receive any net profit proceeds.
(Note: You will still earn your writing fees, production bonuses, and residuals; this discussion focuses solely on profit participation.)
Section 1.1: How Studios "Lose" Money
How do studios consistently appear to be in the red despite numerous box office successes? While the intricacies are complex and I don’t profess to be a specialist, here's a simplified version of how studios typically operate.
Let’s say you are awarded the writing assignment for Slinky: The Movie at Studio A. After drafting your screenplay and receiving the green light, the process unfolds as follows:
Studio A establishes a subsidiary, Slinky Movie, Inc., through which all financial transactions for the project will flow.
During this process, the studio deducts costs associated with production overhead from Slinky Movie, Inc. — let’s estimate this at around 15%.
Next, they deduct marketing overhead, also about 15%.
Finally, they take out distribution overhead, which can be substantial due to infrastructural costs—let's estimate this at 30%.
Are these figures reflective of actual costs? It’s anyone’s guess! Studios don’t allow outsiders to scrutinize their accounting records. The reality is that approximately 60% of Slinky: The Movie’s budget gets expensed upfront, along with any additional costs they can allocate to the ledger. This situation is common practice in Hollywood.
Subsection 1.1.1: The Impact of Gross Profit Deals
Additionally, there are arrangements involving gross profit participation for high-profile actors or directors. Various interpretations of 'gross' exist, but the key takeaway for those of us with net agreements is that the funds earmarked for gross participants are distributed first, further diminishing any potential net profits from the film.
For further reading on this subject, you can explore these articles:
- Murphy movie made millions but stayed in the red, studio ledgers say
- 'Forrest Gump' has yet to make a net profit
- Hanks sues over profit on 'Greek Wedding'
To delve deeper, consider this scholarly article by law professor Mark Weinstein: "Profit-Sharing Contracts in Hollywood: Evolution and Analysis."
Section 1.2: Strategies for Screenwriters
As a screenwriter aiming for profit participation, your best bet is to become a prominent writer who can negotiate a gross position. Otherwise, you’re left with a net percentage, and when it comes to net profits...
You receive nothing.
Thus, it's yet another reason for the WGA to continue advocating for a fair deal.
Chapter 2: The Financial Landscape of Hollywood
In the video titled "The Fastest European Unicorn EVER! $0-2 Billion in 14 months: Philip Belamant Co-Founder, Zilch," Philip Belamant shares insights on financial strategies that can lead to rapid growth in business, reflecting the complexity of profit generation in Hollywood.
The second video, "Astro Bot Net Profit Trophy Guide," offers a humorous perspective on profit-sharing in the gaming industry, drawing parallels to the challenges faced by screenwriters in Hollywood.