Rethinking Hiring Practices: The Value of Diverse Perspectives
Written on
Chapter 1: The Fallacy of "Best" Candidates
In a recent conversation with a business colleague—a white, Catholic man in his sixties—corporate diversity initiatives were brought to light. He referenced a CEO from an airline advocating for increased hiring of Black and female pilots. His retort echoed a familiar refrain often heard from those skeptical of affirmative action: “I don’t mind, as long as they’re the best. But don’t just hire someone to meet a quota.”
At first glance, this perspective appears reasonable—prioritizing excellence over arbitrary gender and race quotas. However, this outlook is flawed. Does the older white male simply need to fit a mold, while the Black woman must be exceptional to be considered?
The underlying assumption is that hiring is based on finding the "best," but this is a misleading notion. In reality, hiring decisions are often made based on who is deemed qualified, regardless of whether their skills are merely adequate or outstanding. The question remains—by what standards do we determine someone is the best?
In truth, if we genuinely aimed to hire the best, we would need to evaluate every qualified candidate globally, which is impractical and ultimately futile.
The evidence shows that many institutions struggle with the hiring process, often making poor choices due to inherent biases unrelated to actual performance.
Moneyball: A Lesson in Talent Identification
If you've read Michael Lewis's "Moneyball: The Art of Winning an Unfair Game," or seen the film adaptation starring Brad Pitt and Jonah Hill, you may recognize the flaws in traditional hiring practices. As highlighted in the story, individuals are frequently overlooked due to biases related to age, appearance, race, and other superficial factors.
The reality is that we tend to hire individuals who mirror our own backgrounds and viewpoints, seeking comfort in familiarity. This tendency can lead to missed opportunities for exceptional talent that doesn't fit the conventional mold.
Understanding Multiple Intelligences
Howard Gardner, a Harvard psychologist, contended that intelligence is not singular but exists in various forms. He identified several types, including:
- Musical: Sensitivity to sounds and rhythms.
- Spatial: Ability to visualize and manipulate spatial concepts.
- Linguistic: Proficiency in language and communication.
- Logical: Aptitude for reasoning and problem-solving.
- Physical: Coordination and physical skill.
- Interpersonal: Understanding others' emotions and motivations.
- Intrapersonal: Self-awareness and introspection.
- Naturalist: Ability to recognize and categorize elements in the environment.
These diverse intelligences highlight that there is no single way to measure capability, and hiring should reflect this complexity.
Challenging the Notion of "Best"
The concept of being the "best" is inherently subjective and varies based on context and criteria. The idea of finding the best candidate often overlooks the potential of individuals who may bring unique perspectives and skills that differ from the norm.
To foster innovation, organizations should prioritize hiring for diversity—not just in demographics but in thought and perspective. Instead of seeking candidates who resemble the existing workforce, consider those who can offer fresh insights and approaches.
Broadening the Hiring Perspective
Encourage hiring practices that seek individuals with differing cultural, racial, or experiential backgrounds. For instance, if your team is predominantly male, consider adding more women. If it’s primarily white and culturally homogeneous, look for candidates who can introduce new viewpoints.
Moreover, understanding candidates on a personal level—what drives them, their passions, and unique talents—can offer valuable insights into how they may contribute to your organization.
Ultimately, expanding your hiring lens can cultivate a richer, more innovative environment. As the saying goes, “If two people agree on everything, one of them is unnecessary.” Embrace the opportunity to diversify your team and broaden your understanding of potential.
In this video, "5 Common Hiring Myths That People Actually Believe Are True!" explore the misconceptions surrounding hiring practices and how they can impact your organization.
The second video, "WHY THE BEST PERSON FOR THE JOB DOESN'T GET IT," dives into the reasons why deserving candidates often miss out on opportunities, shedding light on biases within the hiring process.
If you enjoyed this content, consider following David Todd McCarty for more insights. For those not yet subscribed to Medium, join to access a wealth of engaging articles from various writers.